Letter to the Editor: The Professor Watchlist

By Chris Dietrich

One of the seemingly minor outcomes of the 2016 election has been the creation of the Professor Watchlist, a website that claims to “expose” college professors who “advance leftist propaganda in the classroom.”

In a period in which documented hate crimes are on the rise and in which social media death threats are ever more common, this is more than just a polarizing action.  It is important not to stretch historical analogies too far.  But this type of cruel venture is reminiscent of McCarthyism and its philistine going-over and punishment of academic work not for its content but for what was then described as its “political fitness.”

Certainly our world is different from the late 1950s.  We are not recovering from total war and the destructiveness of atomic power is often an afterthought.  History does not repeat itself, but it does echo.  If the Professor Watchlist seems a dim echo of McCarthyism, it is a disgraceful and malicious one.  Attempts to censor through fear have no place in our society.  Those who wish to do so have as much right to intimidate scholars as an adder has to be at the altar of a chapel.

The historians I know who are on this list are hardly radical.  (And if they were, it would be their right.)  Rather, they do what historians do.  They sift through evidence and try to understand how people have lived, loved, and believed.  They have done no more than reaffirm the most important value of our scholarship and teaching: the pursuit of knowledge based on free and independent discussion.  

To argue otherwise is also to argue that students cannot make their own choices in the marketplace of ideas.  If this trend becomes more acute, the United States will look even more like the sort of society to which it wishes be juxtaposed.


Chris Dietrich

Assistant Professor, Department of History

There are 2 comments

  1. Jack Walton FC'72

    Appropriate to Dr. Dietrich’s specific field of study, when I left Fordham for Grad Study an assigned text was “Management and Macchievelli” — and the phrase “ejus regio, ejus oleum” comes to mind! Our world is different from 1950, but in many respects quite the same. “McCarthyism” remains a red herring for many, but as history demonstrates, McCarthy was correct.


Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s