The Fordham Ram

Time to Reward the Best

Corey+Kluber+and+the+Cleveland+Indians+will+have+home+field+advantage+to+start+the+World+Series.+%28Courtesy+of+Wikimedia%29
Back to Article
Back to Article

Time to Reward the Best

Corey Kluber and the Cleveland Indians will have home field advantage to start the World Series. (Courtesy of Wikimedia)

Corey Kluber and the Cleveland Indians will have home field advantage to start the World Series. (Courtesy of Wikimedia)

Corey Kluber and the Cleveland Indians will have home field advantage to start the World Series. (Courtesy of Wikimedia)

Corey Kluber and the Cleveland Indians will have home field advantage to start the World Series. (Courtesy of Wikimedia)


Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






By Drew Casey 

Corey Kluber and the Cleveland Indians will have home field advantage to start the World Series. (Courtesy of Wikimedia)

Corey Kluber and the Cleveland Indians will have home field advantage to start the World Series. (Courtesy of Wikimedia)

As the 2016 World Series continues, it’s time to change the way home field advantage is determined for the annual Fall Classic.

Despite dominating the early rounds of this year’s playoffs, the 94-win Indians do not deserve to be the home team over the 103-win Cubs. It just doesn’t make sense. The best team over the course of a grueling, 162-game season more than deserves the advantage to play four of a possible seven games at its home ballpark.

Since 2003, home field in the seven game series has been determined by the result of the season’s All-Star Game months earlier. The victorious team in the Midsummer Classic is rewarded with its pennant winner enjoying home field advantage in the same year’s World Series. Regardless of playoff seed or path to playoff qualification among the pennant winners, the method of determining home field does not change. It’s simply based on the All-Star Game result.

Some might say that home field advantage in the World Series doesn’t mean much and thus this argument is invalid, but that is not the case. Since this became the policy, nine of the last 13 World Series champions have taken home the crown with home field advantage at their disposal.

My biggest frustration with all of this, though, is centered on the structure of the annual All-Star Game. First, every Big League club must be represented in the Midsummer Classic. As a result of this requirement, each All-Star team is not made up of the league’s best players. Some of the league’s best individual talents have to be left off to accommodate the biggest “star” on a struggling club.

Another issue is the place of the fan vote in the All-Star Game. Fans pick the starters for the game, with the exception of the starting pitchers. As evidenced, especially in the past two years, this can result in vote inflation and unfair voting practices. In 2015 Royals fans rallied to nearly select an entire Kansas City starting lineup, while earlier this year Cubs supporters voted an all North Side infield into the Midsummer Classic in San Diego.

Third, if an All-Star manager should do his best to get everyone into the game on precedent, how can the game count for so much? A manager or coach who wants to win cannot work effectively with such a prevalent unwritten rule on the table.

By no means am I suggesting that Major League Baseball abolish the All-Star Game.

They should simply make it an exhibition of the game’s biggest stars. Fans will still tune in and look forward to the game each July.

In a time when the sport is transitioning to adapt to the baseball fan of 2016, the process of awarding home field advantage in the World Series goes against the very integrity of America’s pastime.

While the bases are still 90 feet apart both in Cleveland and in Chicago, I would certainly be frustrated as a Cubs fan, and not just because it’s been 108 years.

Leave a Comment

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Left
  • Time to Reward the Best

    Baseball

    Baseball Sweeps in First Weekend in the Bronx

  • Time to Reward the Best

    Baseball

    Luis Severino’s Injury Could Spell Trouble for Yankees

  • Time to Reward the Best

    Baseball

    Baseball Takes Three of Four Against Maryland Eastern Shore

  • Time to Reward the Best

    Baseball

    Beyond the Scoreboard: Who Runs the World? Pitchers

  • Time to Reward the Best

    Baseball

    Baseball Secures First Wins of 2019 Against North Florida

  • Time to Reward the Best

    Baseball

    Baseball Starts Season By Suffering Sweep to Texas A&M

  • Time to Reward the Best

    Baseball

    The Pick-Me-Up Baseball’s All-Star Game Needs

  • Time to Reward the Best

    Baseball

    Is Anyone Alive Out There?

  • Time to Reward the Best

    Baseball

    Beyond the Scoreboard: Loyalty, Loyalty, Loyalty

  • Time to Reward the Best

    Baseball

    Beyond the Scoreboard: Kyler Murray’s Big Risk

Navigate Right
Fordham University's Journal of Record Since 1918
Time to Reward the Best